Status updates for UnsolvedMath entries (our preprints + stale "open" labels)

#4
by AlperTheKing - opened

Hello, and thank you for curating UnsolvedMath. Over the past weeks we worked through the dataset and would like to report two kinds of status information so that others can avoid duplicated effort. All our results are unrefereed preprints with Zenodo DOIs, produced with substantial AI assistance (disclosed in each paper) and each checked by an independent AI audit pass (not human refereeing); please treat them accordingly.

A. Entries addressed by our preprints

Categories are based on an independent audit of each preprint against the exact dataset statement. Entries already marked solved in the dataset are listed last, as independent verifications only.

Resolved as stated (8)

Entry Preprint What is established DOI
AIM-ALGEBRAIC_NUMBER_THEORY-0109 A Positive-Rank Elliptic Curve with No Dense Prime Negative answer: the rank-one curve y^2 = x^3 - 1516563 has E(Q) dense in E(Q_p) for no prime p. 10.5281/zenodo.22245533
AIM-ARITHMETIC_GEOMETRY-0067 A Seventeen-Dimensional Component of the Hilbert Scheme of Eighteen Points on an Integral Curve Yes: an integral projective rational curve (one non-Gorenstein point) whose Hilb^18 has a 17-dimensional component; in characteristic 0 this gives (d-1)-dimensional components of Hilb^d for all d >= 18. 10.5281/zenodo.22328080
AIM-ARITHMETIC_GEOMETRY-0078 A Generically Nonreduced Component for Hilbert Function (1,4,10,10) Settles the remaining case a = 10 left open by Jelisiejew (2024): in characteristic 0 the very-compressed locus for Hilbert function (1,4,10,10) is a generically nonreduced component; with Jelisiejew's a = 6..9 all cases are answered. 10.5281/zenodo.22328644
AIM-DYNAMICAL_SYSTEMS-0095 Ramification Portraits of Rigid Lattès Maps Complete list of weighted ramification portraits of rigid Lattès maps; every flexible portrait is realised by a rigid map in every degree (related branched-cover data: Pascali-Petronio 2009). 10.5281/zenodo.22245386
AIM-FUNCTIONAL_ANALYSIS-0027 Forcing Absoluteness of Minimal and Maximal C∗-Tensor Products Minimal and maximal C*-tensor products of ground-model C*-algebras are preserved (after completion) by every set-forcing extension, with no cardinal-preservation hypothesis. 10.5281/zenodo.22245547
AIM-PROBABILITY-0111 Nonuniformity of Free-Gradient Heat Semigroups under Finite Fisher Information No: with finite free Fisher information the free heat semigroup never converges uniformly to the identity on the unit ball (explicit L^2 lower bound). New for m = 1, 2; m >= 3 follows from Dabrowski-Ioana (2016). 10.5281/zenodo.22327310
AIM-PROBABILITY-0126 A Slice–Riesz–Bochner Characterization of Joint Brown Determinant Functions Characterisation of joint Brown determinant functions log Delta(1 - sum a_j T_j) by slice subharmonicity and a positive-definiteness condition. 10.5281/zenodo.22245595
AMR-011-0025 A Free-Uniform-Spanning-Forest Proof of Finite-Index Multiplicativity Yes: a free-uniform-spanning-forest proof that the first L^2-Betti number is multiplicative on finite-index subgroups, without using multiplicativity of von Neumann dimension. 10.5281/zenodo.22245583

Resolved in the precise sense stated in the note (2)

Entry Preprint What is established DOI
AIM-ALGEBRAIC_GEOMETRY-0125 Smooth Hypersurfaces Beyond the Chevalley-Warning Range over Prime Fields Smooth reading: for every prime p, n >= 2 and d >= n+1 there is a smooth degree-d hypersurface over F_p with #X(F_p) not 1 mod p, hence not rationally connected (without smoothness the question was classical). 10.5281/zenodo.22514087
EP-278 An Exact Fixed-Parameter Algorithm for Extremal Unions of Residue Classes Maximum-density half: an exact characterisation and a fixed-parameter exact algorithm (2^{O(r^2)} poly(input)); the minimum half was settled by Simpson (1986). Whether an exact algorithm counts as an answer to 'what is the maximum density' is for the maintainers to judge. 10.5281/zenodo.22244392

Special case only; the general question remains open (2)

Entry Preprint What is established DOI
AIM-REPRESENTATION_THEORY-0023 Quantum Symmetric Algebras on Multiple Standard Copies: Structure and Categorical Non-Equivalence Negative answer for several copies of the standard representation (the case singled out in the problem's remark); the general quantum Sym(S_lambda) question remains open. 10.5281/zenodo.22635788
AIM-SEVERAL_COMPLEX_VARIABLES-0010 An Explicit Rational Homotopy from the Faran Map to a Linear Map in Target Dimension Four An explicit proper rational homotopy from the Faran map to a linear map (B^2 to B^4); the general classification question remains open. 10.5281/zenodo.22662513

Only the literal reading is settled; the intended question remains open (3)

Entry Preprint What is established DOI
AIM-COMBINATORICS-0233 Power-Saving Lower Bounds for Additive Bases of Polynomial Sequences Power-saving lower bounds beyond the trivial exponent for bases of polynomial sequences; this settles only the literal qualitative question, good/optimal bounds remain open. 10.5281/zenodo.22245345
AIM-DYNAMICAL_SYSTEMS-0011 Maximal Finite-Set Stabilizers in Thompson's Group T An infinite family of maximal subgroups of infinite index in Thompson's group T (stabilisers of k dyadic points, isomorphic to F wr C_k); the open-ended request for genuinely new kinds of maximal subgroups remains open. 10.5281/zenodo.22324898
AIM-GEOMETRY-0263 A Compactness Obstruction to Linear Growth Along Null Geodesics Negative answer to the literal universal question (no one-form with nonzero slope along every null geodesic); the intended zero-slope statement remains open. 10.5281/zenodo.22245396

Already marked solved in the dataset — our preprint is an independent verification/write-up (10)

Entry Preprint What is established DOI
AIM-ANALYSIS-0015 The Spectrum of the Hilbert Matrix on Power-Weighted ℓ² Spaces Full spectral picture of the Hilbert matrix on power-weighted l^2 (spectrum, fine parts, index); the spectrum set and radius were announced earlier by Aleman-Siskakis-Vukotic. 10.5281/zenodo.22245611
AIM-COMBINATORICS-0230 Lacunary Counterexamples to a Distinct-Summand Freiman Container Problem Elementary proof of the negative answer via lacunary sets; the same construction appears in the dataset's own research record. 10.5281/zenodo.22245483
AIM-DYNAMICAL_SYSTEMS-0005 Maximal Generic Iterated Galois Images Do Not Determine p-Adic Julia Sets Negative answer: z^2+1 and z^2-p^{-6} over Q_p have the same maximal iterated Galois groups but different Julia sets (uses Pink's unpublished preprint Thm 1.10.2). 10.5281/zenodo.22245331
AIM-GEOMETRIC_GROUP_THEORY-0027 Free-by-Cyclic Groups with Unboundedly Many BNS Component Orbits Free-by-cyclic groups with unboundedly many Out-orbits of BNS components; the same construction appears in the dataset's own record and an earlier public note (doi:10.5281/zenodo.22201487). 10.5281/zenodo.22245655
AIM-GEOMETRY-0175 Complex Sectional Curvature Blow-Up under Circle Cheeger Collapse No: complex sectional curvature tends to -infinity under circle Cheeger collapse with a fixed component of codimension >= 4. 10.5281/zenodo.22245130
AIM-GEOMETRY-0195 Angle-Data Reconstruction for Triangulated Polyhedral Surfaces and a Genus Deficit Angle data determine realisations; the AIM dimension formula E-1 holds for genus 0 and fails for every genus >= 1. 10.5281/zenodo.22245788
AIM-GEOMETRY-0274 Parallel Nilpotent Endomorphisms Without Parallel Null Vectors No: a closed flat (8,8)-manifold with a parallel self-adjoint square-zero endomorphism but no parallel null vector, even on double covers. 10.5281/zenodo.22245515
AIM-TOPOLOGY-0102 A Four-Point Counterexample to Excision for Directed Cubical Homology of Closure Spaces Four-point counterexample: excision fails for directed cubical homology of closure spaces. 10.5281/zenodo.22245271
AIM-TOPOLOGY-0203 Variable Critical Exponents on a Fixed Free-Deck Regular Cover Yes: a fixed free-deck regular cover whose critical exponent varies over Teichmüller space. 10.5281/zenodo.22245803
AMR-011-0004 Adjoining a Haar-Generic Matrix to a Parabolic-Free Subgroup of SL₂(Qₚ) Yes: for Haar-almost every g, <Gamma, g> remains parabolic-free. 10.5281/zenodo.22245813

B. Entries labelled open that are already resolved elsewhere

Entries Problem Status Source
SET-001 (records 22 and 1135) Continuum hypothesis Independent of ZFC Continuum hypothesis
ALG-003 (record 1448), ALG-004 (record 1104) Connes embedding problem Solved (false / counterexample) MIP*=RE (arXiv:2001.04383)
HIL-018 Hilbert's 18th problem Solved (true) Hilbert's eighteenth problem
HIL-007 Hilbert's 7th problem Solved (true) Hilbert's seventh problem
HIL-014 Hilbert's 14th problem Solved (false / counterexample) Hilbert's fourteenth problem - Wikipedia
HIL-017 Hilbert's 17th problem Solved (true) Hilbert's seventeenth problem - Wikipedia
OWR-12177-008, OWR-2043-007 Polynomial Freiman-Ruzsa conjecture over F_2^n Solved (true) Marton's 'Polynomial Freiman-Ruzsa' Conjecture was
ALG-016 Graph isomorphism in quasi-polynomial time Solved (true) Graph isomorphism problem
ALG-014 (record 1114), OWR-1265-004 McKay conjecture Solved (Cabanes–Späth, arXiv:2410.20392, to appear in Annals) McKay conjecture
GRAPH-003 (record 1327), GRAPH-029, GT-004, OPG-137, AMR-030-0019 Cycle double cover conjecture Solved: proof announced by OpenAI (July 2026); expositions by S. Oum and J. Geelen; unrefereed A proof of the cycle double cover conjecture by Op
GEO-029, OWR-14298163-006 Borsuk's conjecture Refuted (Kahn-Kalai 1993); the minimal counterexample dimension is still open Borsuk's conjecture
ALG-003 (records 38 and 1103), ALG-010 (record 1455) Köthe conjecture Refuted: two independent preprints (Sept 2026), unrefereed A counterexample to Köthe's conjecture and a quest
DYN-002 (record 1142) Painlevé conjecture Solved (Xia 1992; Xue, Acta Math. 2020) Painlevé conjecture
SET-002 (record 1176) Suslin's problem Independent of ZFC Suslin's problem - Wikipedia
ALG-030 Generalized moonshine Solved (true) Monstrous Moonshine over Z? (arXiv:1804.04161), Ca
OPG-806 Hedetniemi's conjecture Solved (false / counterexample) Hedetniemi's conjecture
SET-003 Whitehead problem Independent of ZFC Whitehead problem
ALG-025 Guralnick-Thompson conjecture Solved (true) Frohardt-Magaard, Ann. of Math. 154 (2001)
GRAPH-052 Implicit graph conjecture Solved (false / counterexample) Implicit graph conjecture
ALG-004 (records 1300 and 1449) Crouzeix's conjecture Solved: preprints July-Aug 2026 (S. Jin; E. Lorist-F. Schwenninger), unrefereed Crouzeix's conjecture
SMA-016, OPG-1768, OWR-1452-011 Jacobian conjecture (all dimensions) False for every n >= 3 (the planar case n = 2 remains open) T. Tao, A digestion of the Jacobian conjecture cou
OWR-1452-013 Dixmier conjecture (all ranks) Not true in all ranks: the stable Dixmier and Jacobian conjectures are equivalent (Tsuchimoto 2005; Belov-Kanel-Kontsevich 2007), so the July 2026 Jacobian counterexample refutes it (ranks >= 3 via the classical implication Dixmier(n) => Jacobian(n); ranks 1-2 open) Belov-Kanel, Kontsevich, Mosc. Math. J. 7 (2007)

We would also gently suggest re-labelling Hilbert's 6th problem (HIL-006), Hilbert's 11th problem (HIL-011), Hilbert's 15th problem (HIL-015, ALG-018), Hilbert–Pólya conjecture (NT-068) as research programmes rather than open yes/no problems.

A machine-readable version (JSON) is available on request. Corrections welcome.

— Alper Ferudun (Mercury Software GmbH), https://eulersolve.org/papers/

Follow-up (2026-09-27): more stale "open" labels, found by syncing with sources that maintain status data. Again, this is only meant to save others duplicated effort.

1. Erdős problems. All 632 EP-* entries are labelled open in v1.6.0. As of today, erdosproblems.com lists 90 of them as resolved (we fetched each page; many resolutions are recent, several by AI systems, and most are Lean-verified). Grouped by the site's status:

The site's machine-readable status file (teorth/erdosproblems, data/problems.yaml) may be the easiest way to keep these entries in sync.

2. Ben Green's 100 open problems. The current version of the list (updated December 2025) marks these as solved. Note that the dataset's GREEN-xxx numbers differ from the numbering in Green's list.

Entry Green's problem Status Source
GREEN-001 Problem 1 (sum-free subsets of size n/3 + ω(n)) Solved: every n-set of integers has a sum-free subset of size n/3 + c log log n B. Bedert, arXiv:2502.08624
GREEN-069 Problem 26 (sums of 100 "cubes" in F_3^n) Solved (yes, already with 4 cubes); the F_p analogue remains open Y. Yu, arXiv:2510.01300
GREEN-040 Problem 67 (Waring's problem over finite fields) Marked solved by Green: asymptotic formula with s = O(k) for p ≥ 2k W. Sawin, arXiv:2412.14053

3. OWR-1452-012 (Zhao's Vanishing Conjecture for homogeneous quartics). Zhao proved that this conjecture, over all n, is equivalent to the Jacobian conjecture over all n (Trans. AMS 359 (2007), arXiv:math/0409534). The July 2026 Jacobian counterexample (see SMA-016 above) therefore refutes it for some n; we have not identified the smallest such n.

— Alper Ferudun

Follow-up 2 (2026-09-27): Kourovka Notebook, issue 21 (KOU-21.*). The arXiv version of the notebook updated today (arXiv:1401.0300v46) marks the following issue-21 problems as solved (asterisk), while v1.6.0 still labels them open:

Entry Answer (per the notebook) Source cited in the notebook
KOU-21.10 Yes (every finite group has a just finite presentation) M. Lackenby, arXiv:2605.10402
KOU-21.87 Yes J. DeCaro (preprint, July 2026); R. Sater, arXiv:2608.12432
KOU-21.88 No, there are no such groups B. Beyer de Ryke, arXiv:2608.03003
KOU-21.97 Yes S. Sureaux (preprint, 2026, linked from the notebook)
KOU-21.117 Yes, for both questions (Thompson's group V) R. Sauer, E. Schesler, arXiv:2605.30163
KOU-21.134 No, for both questions (already answered by J. G. Thompson) Y. Li, W. Shi, Ric. Mat. 74 (2025) 559–563
KOU-21.137 No (counterexamples for p = 3 and p = 2) K. Muliarchyk (preprint, 2026); A. Chang (letter, 2026)
KOU-21.142 No (for any primes p ≠ q) T. Gong, M. R. Zeng, Y. Yang, arXiv:2608.00703; I. Capdeboscq, C. Parker, arXiv:2608.03935
KOU-21.147 No, not always P. Monticone (preprint, 2026); van Doorn, Judin, Monticone, Morrison, arXiv:2607.17477

(The other nine starred issue-21 problems, 21.8, 21.12, 21.14, 21.15, 21.18, 21.24, 21.43, 21.58, 21.150, are already marked solved in the dataset.)

— Alper Ferudun

Follow-up 3 (2026-09-27): KOU-21.68 — new counterexample (our own result, unrefereed). Kourovka Notebook Problem 21.68 (M. Kida) conjectures that every finite semi-abelian group is monomial. This is false. There is a semi-abelian group of order 768 = 2^8·3 with a non-monomial irreducible character of degree 8:

  • Ĝ = B ⋊ W, where W = E ⋊ A₄ is the index-two subgroup of C₂ ≀ A₄, T ≅ SL(2,3) ≤ W is the binary tetrahedral group acting on the eight quaternion units, and B is the augmentation (even-weight) submodule of the permutation module F₂[W/T].
  • General reduction (Clifford theory): if a linear character of the abelian normal subgroup N has stabiliser T in W and T has a non-monomial irreducible character, then N ⋊ W is not an M-group.
  • Checked by exact computation, including every subgroup of index 8 and the full character table of Ĝ (exactly the three degree-8 irreducible characters are non-monomial). Scripts are in the source archive.

Preprint: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23000305 · paper page: https://eulersolve.org/papers/kou-21-68/

Suggested label: solved (answered negatively). It has not been peer-reviewed yet, so independent checks are welcome. Minimality of the order is not claimed; Kida's Magma search covered all orders up to 240.

— Alper Ferudun

Follow-up 4 (2026-09-27): internal status inconsistency. For 188 problem numbers, the literature-triage block inside the record itself ("Literature review (checked 2026-08-17)", Status: solved, Classification: SOLVED-IN-LITERATURE) disagrees with the status field, which still says open (same in v1.6.0 and v1.7.0). 94 of them are already covered in the comments above; the remaining 94 are listed below by source so they can be reconciled in one pass. We have not re-verified each triage conclusion ourselves, and some of them refute a literal wording rather than the intended question, so they are pointers, not claims.

  • HIL (1): HIL-009
  • SMA (1): SMA-004
  • NT (5): NT-008, NT-023, NT-035, NT-037, NT-086
  • GREEN (3): GREEN-061, GREEN-064, GREEN-100
  • GEO (3): GEO-004, GEO-006, GEO-028
  • GEOM (1): GEOM-026
  • GT (1): GT-008
  • GRAPH (4): GRAPH-006, GRAPH-008, GRAPH-046, GRAPH-049
  • TOP (1): TOP-003
  • ALG (2): ALG-033, ALG-036
  • COMB (2): COMB-012, COMB-004
  • HL (1): HL-F
  • GUY (3): GUY-A8a, GUY-A11, GUY-A15
  • KP (6): KP-1.51, KP-3.14, KP-4.37, KP-4.125, KP-5.9, KP-5.15
  • OPG (51): OPG-23298, OPG-50149, OPG-37185, OPG-426, OPG-1797, OPG-37167, OPG-37181, OPG-37230, OPG-692, OPG-37086, OPG-610, OPG-37341, OPG-34908, OPG-37081, OPG-37089, OPG-37218, OPG-37316, OPG-37364, OPG-57613, OPG-59952, OPG-59997, OPG-824, OPG-46606, OPG-47285, OPG-59911, OPG-2242, OPG-59994, OPG-616, OPG-36939, OPG-52200, OPG-47031, OPG-47643, OPG-37305, OPG-47646, OPG-677, OPG-690, OPG-691, OPG-735, OPG-177, OPG-157, OPG-732, OPG-760, OPG-2379, OPG-37444, OPG-37863, OPG-37402, OPG-655, OPG-1783, OPG-37245, OPG-37295, OPG-57401
  • EP (9): EP-129, EP-520, EP-524, EP-545, EP-550, EP-612, EP-638, EP-654, EP-996 — note that erdosproblems.com still lists all nine as open (EP-550 as "open (Lean)"), so these triage conclusions deserve a second look before relabelling.

A JSON list (problem number, status field, triage status) is available on request.

— Alper Ferudun

ulam.ai org

Hello, thank you for these detailed additions! They are now integrated.

Follow-up 5 (2026-09-28): two new results, one problem already solved in the literature, and corrections to Oberwolfach and Kourovka records (stale statuses, transcription errors, merged records, one misattached note). Each item was checked against the current version (commit 2ea030b). Where a page is given, it was also checked in the report itself; literature was checked against arXiv and Crossref. Suggested changes are in bold.

New results (unrefereed preprints with full proofs, verification scripts and independent referee checks)

  • OWR-12861-021 → solved (no). Heinig's Question 2 (OWR 01/2014, p. 82) has a negative answer for every odd n ≥ 7: K_{(n+1)/2,(n−1)/2} with a perfect matching (or a matching plus one P₃) inside the larger side has minimum degree ⌈n/2⌉ but no spanning copy of the near-square, under both readings of "periphery"; at n = 9, K_{4,4,1} is a counterexample under every reading. For n = 7 the host is Heinig's own graph X (arXiv:1112.5101, Def. 28). The cycle-space Question 1 is not affected (Hou–Yin). Paper: doi:10.5281/zenodo.23004012 (page).
  • KOU-21.76 → solved. The existence question was first answered by Ya. N. Nuzhin, Sib. Math. J. 67 (2026) 840–845, Corollary 1 (examples in every characteristic, over F(y,z)); the notebook (v46) does not record this yet. Our note gives explicit examples with short proofs, including one-variable examples over F₃(t) (which also satisfy the hypotheses of 19.48), and shows that in characteristic 3 such nets exist over K iff K is not algebraic over F₃. Paper: doi:10.5281/zenodo.23004034 (page).

Stale statuses

  • OWR-12330-013 → solved (yes). King answers his own Question 1 on the next page: "The answer to this is yes" (OWR 02/2013, p. 105). K_k with k pendant vertices at every vertex has χ_f = k > 3k/4 + 1 for k ≥ 5.
  • OWR-1319-022 → solved (no). Two word metrics on H₃(ℤ)×ℤ have ratio → 1 but unbounded difference: Breuillard, Groups Geom. Dyn. (2014) (arXiv:0704.0095), and Breuillard–Le Donne, PNAS 110 (2013), §5, who cite this report.
  • OWR-5158-016 → solved (yes). By Deroin–Hurtado (arXiv:2008.10687, Thm 1.3), irreducible lattices in finite-centre semisimple groups of real rank ≥ 2 are not left-orderable, so any cocompact arithmetic lattice in SL(3,ℝ) works. See also Witte Morris's exposition (2026).
  • OWR-14213-006 → solved. The statement is the unit-interval (Hessenberg) form of the Stanley–Stembridge conjecture, proved by Hikita, J. Amer. Math. Soc. (2026) (arXiv:2410.12758).
  • OWR-1386-016 → solved, if "threshold" has its usual coarse meaning (the constant b is then immaterial). This is the two-graph Kohayakawa–Kreuter conjecture: the 1-statement is due to Mousset–Nenadov–Samotij (CPC 2020), and Christoph–Martinsson–Steiner–Wigderson (Proc. LMS 130, 2025) completed the proof. A sharp threshold at b·n^(−1/m₂) would be a different question; we could not re-read the wording in OWR 48/2006.
  • OWR-14299911-005 → solved (disproved). The source itself reports Chalopin–Chepoi's counterexample to the "MSO decidable ⇔ grid-free" conjecture (ACM TOCL 20 (2019)). Please also drop the second sentence: the special-cube-complex result concerns Thiagarajan's other conjecture, and the counterexample itself comes from a virtually special complex.
  • OWR-17294-009 → at least partially solved. Part (1), Byott's question, is answered no by Di Matteo–Ferrara–Trombetti, arXiv:2607.22795 (July 2026 preprint). The record bundles Vendramin's Problems 1, 3 and 5 (OWR 51/2019, p. 3222); splitting it would help.
  • KOU-21.115 → solved (yes). Sambale, arXiv:2609.09052 (September 2026 preprint), proves |G∖U| ≥ |G|/2ⁿ whenever n left cosets have union U ≠ G, and right cosets are left cosets of conjugates. The notebook (v46) has not starred it yet.
  • OWR-4213-002 → solved. The statement is the Feit–Thompson theorem (Pacific J. Math. 13 (1963)). Also, "nontrivial" simple groups should read "non-abelian".
  • OWR-1265-024 → not an open problem. The source poses it as a puzzle and gives the answer C(a+b,a) − C(a+b,a−1), which counts standard (b,a)-tableaux (G. James, OWR 15/2006, pp. 965–966).
  • Pointer only, OWR-11568-005. Lutowski's Theorem 2 (Publ. Math. Debrecen 99 (2021)) says that the holonomy of a non-torus Kähler flat manifold has at least two distinct irreducible constituents. Since h^{1,1}(A/G) = dim End_G(T₀A), this seems to force b₂ ≥ 2 for free torus quotients of dimension ≥ 2. Worth a check.

Transcription errors

  • OWR-12330-010, -011, -012: the ceilings in the source are missing (OWR 02/2013, p. 103, Conj. 3; p. 104, Conj. 4–6). As written, C₅ violates all of them: the right-hand sides are 5/2 or 3 − ε, while χ(C₅) = 3.
  • OWR-1189-007: Kohl's Conjecture 2 reads ⌊3d(1−1/n)⌋ + 1, not ⌈·⌉ (OWR 7/2006, p. 416). As written it is false for d = 1 and n ≥ 4, because χ^{1,1}_ℓ(P_n) = ch(P_n²) = 3.
  • OWR-5154-009: the source puts the profinite closure on the product [g₁]^F⋯[g_k]^F, not on N(g₁,…,g_k) (OWR 26/2011, p. 1452, Conj. 2). As written, the answer is trivially no.
  • OWR-12007-008: with "r, s ∈ ℝ" (the same wording as OWR 35/2012, p. 2173) the question is false for w = a, since R(a,r,s) = r. The source's own results are for rational r, s, so this should read r, s ∈ ℚ.

Merged records

  • OWR-4791-001 merges two conjectures that the organisers' introduction (OWR 1/2011, p. 6) reports as proved: Simonovits–Sós (Ellis–Filmus–Friedgut) and Sumner (for large n, Kühn–Mycroft–Osthus). Splitting it would help.
  • OWR-9790352-039, OWR-10252930-031, OWR-9790352-036: the statement is already clean, but original_statement still contains a neighbouring item, respectively:
    • the Plummer–Zha conjecture, proved during the workshop (OWR 1/2022, p. 71; Chudnovsky–Seymour, JGT 103 (2023));
    • a weighted Turán conjecture, proved by Bradač (arXiv:2205.08923);
    • Narayanan's permanent inequality (OWR 1/2022, pp. 69–70), which is open and has no record of its own.

Misattached note

  • OWR-12861-020: the literature note (Hou–Yin, arXiv:2503.15950) is about Heinig's Question 1 (OWR 01/2014, p. 81), which has no record of its own. It does not concern the Diestel or Friedgut questions in this record, and the record's "partially solved" label rests only on that note.

Correction to Follow-up 2. arXiv:1401.0300v46 (Kourovka Notebook No. 21) was posted on 1 September 2026, not on 27 September as I wrote there; the list of starred problems is unaffected.

— Alper Ferudun

Follow-up 6 (2026-09-28): three new results, and corrections to Oberwolfach combinatorics records (stale statuses, questions answered in their own source, transcription errors, duplicates, merged records, garbled extracts and misattached notes). Each item was checked against the current version (commit 2ea030b). Where a page is given, it was also checked in the report itself; literature was checked against arXiv and Crossref. Suggested changes are in bold.

New results (unrefereed preprints with full proofs, verification scripts and independent referee checks)

  • OWR-16164-019 → solved (no). Sportiello's conjecture B_λ ≥ A_λ (OWR 23/2018, pp. 1455–1457) fails for the band λ = {(x,y) ∈ [7]² : −3 ≤ y−x ≤ 4}, where A_λ = 536 and B_λ = 515. Every digitally convex shape of side ≤ 6 satisfies the inequality; among the 5,693,968 shapes of side 7, only this band and its transpose violate it. (The record attaches the red and blue crosses to the opposite colours; that swap is a bijection on colourings and does not change B_λ.) Paper: doi:10.5281/zenodo.23006715 (page).

  • OWR-1782-009 and OWR-1386-013 (the same conjecture) → false as stated. Both ask that minimum codegree ⌊(n−k+3)/2⌋ force a tight Hamiltonian cycle for all n: for n ≥ k+1 ≥ 4 in OWR 01/2008 (p. 46), and with no range of n in OWR 48/2006 (p. 2928). This all-n form is Conjecture 1.1 of Rödl–Ruciński–Szemerédi, Adv. Math. 227 (2011), who attribute it to Katona–Kierstead. It fails for (k,n) = (3,7), (3,9), (4,8), (5,9) and (5,10). The smallest counterexample is an apex joined to all 15 pairs of a 6-set W, plus the ten faces of the hemi-icosahedron on W. Its pair-degrees are 3 and 5. But in a cyclic order (apex, w₁, …, w₆) the disjoint windows w₁w₂w₃ and w₄w₅w₆ would both have to be faces, and no two faces are disjoint. The (5,10) example has codegree 4 = (n−k+3)/2, so the version without the floor fails too. The large-n statement is not affected: RRS proved it for k = 3, and Letzter–Lang–Ranganathan–Sanhueza-Matamala have announced it for all k ≥ 3, as reported in arXiv:2609.08613. Suggested status: "false as stated (small counterexamples); the large-n form is proved for k = 3 and announced for all k". Also:

    • OWR-1386-013 should say "tight" Hamiltonian cycle, as its source defines it; under a Berge reading these hypergraphs do have Hamiltonian cycles;
    • mark the two records as duplicates;
    • the literature DOIs on OWR-1782-009 concern other thresholds (10.1016/j.jcta.2015.01.004: Hamilton ℓ-cycles with ℓ < k/2; 10.1112/jlms.12561: minimum d-degree conditions). RRS 2011 and arXiv:2609.08613 are the relevant references.

    Paper: doi:10.5281/zenodo.23006718 (page).

  • OWR-14299577-018 → solved (yes, both questions). The problem was proposed by C. Bernert and N. Arala Santos, in the problem session compiled by T. F. Bloom (OWR 51/2025, p. 2756), so proposed_by can be filled in. Let A ⊂ {−n,…,n}∖{0} contain exactly one of k and −k for every k ≤ n. Then at most two elements of [1,n] are missing from A − A. This is sharp: {1,…,a} ∪ {−(a+1),…,−n} misses exactly a and a+1 whenever n/2 ≤ a ≤ n−1. For every B ⊆ [1,n], the number of pairs (a,b) ∈ A² with a − b ∈ B is at least ⌊(|B|−1)²/4⌋, and this is attained for every |B| ≤ ⌊2n/3⌋+1. So for |B| ≥ εn the count is at least (1/4 − o(1))ε²n². The key step is that the representation counts r(d) of any set S of differences of one parity satisfy Σ_{d∈S} r(d) ≥ C(|S|,2), by a double count of the positions where the sign pattern repeats at distance d. The record's original_statement is garbled: it drops the set-up sentence and splices in two sentences from the preceding problem (Assing). Paper: doi:10.5281/zenodo.23006720 (page).

Stale statuses

  • OWR-16160-016 → solved as stated (classical). Valette asks whether the congruence subgroups of G ⊂ SL_N(ℤ) depend on the embedding (OWR 19/2018, p. 1151). In general they do. For example, F₂ embeds as ⟨(1 2; 0 1), (1 0; 2 1)⟩ and as ⟨(1 3; 0 1), (1 0; 3 1)⟩. The level-2 subgroup of the second embedding contains no congruence subgroup of the first, and the level-3 subgroup of the first contains none of the second, so the two congruence topologies are incomparable. Classical instances go back to Serre: SLₙ(ℤ) has congruence subgroups whose images under the adjoint map are not congruence subgroups (Lubotzky–Venkataramana, Algebra Number Theory 13 (2019), Prop. 2.1). For the groups of the talk, Z² ⋊_A Z, the answer is the opposite, and the same holds for every solvable G. Solvable groups have the congruence subgroup property (Chahal, Nagoya Math. J. 79 (1980)), and solvable subgroups of GLₙ(ℤ) are polycyclic, so every embedding induces the profinite topology (LV, §1.1). A scope note would help.
  • OWR-1265-006 → solved (yes). Olsson's containment question (OWR 15/2006, p. 913) is the Olsson–Stanton conjecture. Vandehey proved it (arXiv:0809.2134, 2008), and Fayers gave another proof (JCTA 118 (2011)).
  • OWR-1536-011 → solved (no, both parts). Knox (arXiv:1212.3345) gives a hypergraph on which Breaker, moving second, wins Maker–Breaker, yet Chooser wins Chooser–Picker. Knox notes that the Picker–Chooser part is equivalent to it; the equivalence comes from the transversal-hypergraph duality stated in the source (OWR 20/2007, p. 1095). So the transversal hypergraph of his example refutes the Picker–Chooser part too.
  • OWR-4425-020 (duplicate -021) → solved (yes). Shallit's Conjecture 48 (OWR 37/2010, p. 2236) is Theorem 18 of Cassaigne–Currie–Schaeffer–Shallit, J. ACM 61 (2014), for exactly this morphism.
  • OWR-2090-021 → partially solved. Adiprasito–Björner (arXiv:1401.7301, Thm 2.1) prove the Mikhalkin–Ziegler conjecture from this problem session:
    • for a generic weight and t ≤ min{0, total weight}, the proper flats of weight > t form a homotopy Cohen–Macaulay poset, hence an (r−3)-connected one;
    • the "non-negative" version follows by a small perturbation;
    • they credit rank 3 to Pinchasi–Ziegler (personal communication, 2008);
    • shellability is still open (their Open Problem 3.2).
  • OWR-12481-012 → solved (no). When Friedgut re-posed it for fixed t and large n, the report recorded: "This turns out to be false; a counterexample was found by Gábor Tardos" (OWR 22/2016, p. 1217). The question as posed here already fails for n = 4, t = 2. Pair σ with σ∘(1 2) if σ maps {1,2} onto {1,2} or {3,4}, and with σ∘(3 4) otherwise. The resulting 12 two-cosets refine none of the 8 partitions of S₄ into 1-cosets.
  • OWR-16633-025 → solved (no), over every field. We found no written answer, but a 4-element example settles it: T₀ = F², T₁ = ⟨e₁⟩, T₂ = ⟨e₂⟩, T₃ = ⟨e₁+e₂⟩. Then f(0) = 2, f(1) = f(2) = f(3) = 1, and f(S) = 2 for every other nonempty S. Suppose f = Σ c_j r_j with c_j > 0 and matroid ranks r_j on {0,1,2,3}; the r_j need not even be representable.
    • Every matroid has r(0i) ≥ r(0) and r(ij) ≤ r(i) + r(j). Since f attains equality in both, so does every r_j.
    • So in each r_j, the elements 1, 2 and 3 lie in the closure of 0, which has rank ≤ 1, and at most one of them is a non-loop.
    • Hence r_j(123) = r_j(1) + r_j(2) + r_j(3) for every j, and summing gives f(123) = 3. But f(123) = 2.
    • Over GF(2), 2·r(U₂,₄) is another example. Dougherty–Freiling–Zeger (arXiv:0910.0284, §4) represent it over every field. Its only possible matroid summands are copies of U₂,₄, which is not binary.

Answered in the source itself

  • OWR-4791-006 → solved. Fox–Lee–Sudakov prove both conjectures in the abstract itself (OWR 01/2011, pp. 11–12: Thm 2, f(m) = ⌊√(4m+1)⌋ − 1, and Thm 4). The paper is Israel J. Math. 191 (2012). The record's own verification note already says so.
  • OWR-16931-001 → solved. The record asks only about sufficiently large n. For that case the source says "We answer this affirmatively for all sufficiently large n" (OWR 19/2019, p. 1158). This is Glock–Joos–Kim–Kühn–Osthus, JEMS 23 (2021).
  • OWR-14299518-002 → solved. Alon answers both questions in the abstract itself (OWR 42/2025, pp. 2249–2250): (1) no (Thm 3), (2) yes (Thm 4). These are Erdős problems #664 (disproved) and #732 (proved). The note's "structural characterization" is not part of this record.
  • OWR-12872-010 → solved, and one formula needs fixing. Stanley (with F. Liu) proves both of Elkies' conjectures in the same abstract (OWR 12/2014, pp. 696–697); the paper is Ramanujan J. 36 (2015). For n = 2m the count of maximum families is 2^((m−1)(m−2))·(2^m − 1), not ·(2m − 1). A brute-force count gives 28 for n = 6 and 960 for n = 8.

Transcription errors and literal readings

  • OWR-14298158-004: Claesson's conjecture is monotonicity in the length n for fixed k: |Av_n^k(1324)| ≤ |Av_{n+1}^k(1324)| (OWR 6/2024, p. 284; Claesson–Jelínek–Steingrímsson, JCTA 119 (2012)). The same correction applies to the Av(1324, 231) part. As written (k → k+1), the statement is false for every n, e.g. |Av_{2,1}| = 1 > 0 = |Av_{2,2}|.
  • OWR-17135-030, -031, -032: the source prints M_ii = Σ_{S∋i}|S| (OWR 39/2019, p. 2464). This is a typo for Σ_{S∋i} X_S = deg(i).
    • With that diagonal, det M = |X|·|Y|·τ(G)/∏_{y∈Y} deg y. So Conjecture 5 becomes equivalent to Ehrenborg's Conjecture 4, as the source says.
    • As printed, Conjecture 5 is false. Take X = [3], hang 13 leaves on each vertex of X, and add one vertex joined to all three. Then det M = 850 > 512 = det(diag M). It also fails if the sum runs only over the sets S that occur.
    • With the corrected diagonal, Conjecture 5 is Ehrenborg's conjecture, proved by Ho (arXiv:2603.17997; -030 already cites it).
    • The refinement in -031/-032 is false as literally stated, already at n = 3. There det(diag M) − det M is homogeneous of degree 3 with coefficient −1/4 on X₁₂X₁₃X₂₃. No such polynomial equals Σc_μx^μ + Σc_μν(x^μ − x^ν)² with all c ≥ 0, because the square terms would contribute a nonzero part of even degree. If multipliers x^ρ(x^μ − x^ν)² were intended, the record should say so.
  • OWR-14299089-007: as written, the question is trivial: (a_n b_n)² ≥ a_{n−1}a_{n+1}b_{n−1}b_{n+1} for nonnegative sequences. The source asks Brändén–Ferroni–Jochemko's Question 6.1 (Trans. AMS 2026, arXiv:2408.12386). Write Σ p(n)xⁿ = W(p)/(1−x)^(deg p+1). If W(p) and W(q) are log-concave with no internal zeros, is W(pq)?
  • OWR-11695867-010: as the source itself says (OWR 57/2022, p. 3274), the case ℓ = 0, Σ f_λ² = n!, is "exactly the Robinson-Schensted-Knuth algorithm". Louf's Open problem 1 is a bijective proof of n!·H_{n,ℓ} = Σ_{λ⊢n} f_λ² C_λ^ℓ for all ℓ. Here H_{n,ℓ} counts ℓ-tuples of transpositions with product 1, and C_λ is the content sum.
  • OWR-16164-005: the literal question has a classical answer. Put y_i = 1 − x_i for odd i; each constraint then becomes y_i ≤ y_{i+1} or y_i ≥ y_{i+1}. So the polytope is the order polytope of a fence, a poset whose Hasse diagram is the path 1–2–⋯–n. Its Ehrhart polynomial is Ω(P, t+1) (Stanley, DCG 1 (1986)), so h* is the descent polynomial of its linear extensions (natural labelling). We checked this for all 63 sign sequences with n ≤ 6. Mark solved, or restate if another interpretation was intended.

Duplicates

  • Across reports: OWR-12481-012 is the Friedgut half of OWR-12861-020 (OWR 18/2013, p. 1118; OWR 01/2014, p. 81). Splitting OWR-12861-020 would leave there only Diestel's k-block question, which is open.
  • New: OWR-14299904-003 repeats -002, which is Weigandt's Conjecture 1 (OWR 2/2026, p. 133); -004 is Conjecture 2.
  • Already flagged: the following records are marked as repeats in their own statement_verification, but are still published as open or partially solved. So each of these problems is counted twice. A duplicate status, or unpublishing, would help. The records are OWR-734-010, OWR-1183-007, -012, OWR-4425-019, -021, OWR-4791-016, OWR-4798-022, OWR-11136-011, OWR-14604-015, OWR-16633-022, -024, OWR-16763-026, -028, OWR-17135-032 and OWR-1703876-017.

Merged records

  • OWR-1703876-016 (duplicate -017) bundles Problems 6–10 of the OWR 30/2020 problem session (p. 1522), posed by five different people. Splitting would help. Two of its notes need fixing:
    • Problem 10 (Welzl, partial triangulations) is solved (yes) by Kupavskii–Volostnov–Yarovikov, Europ. J. Combin. 108 (2023) (arXiv:2104.05855). -017 lists that arXiv paper under the names Aichholzer–Orden–Schnider.
    • Problem 8 (Steiner, bichromatic triangles) is still open. -016 says a 2026 preprint proves it. In fact Radtke–Keszegh–Lauff (arXiv:2601.20574) prove it only for at most 5 red pseudolines (so for n ≤ 11). In general they prove only that a two-coloured triangle or quadrangle exists.
  • OWR-4425-003 bundles Currie's Open problems 2–4 (OWR 37/2010, p. 2206): Restivo–Salemi reachability, the curling-number conjecture and the lexicographically least 5/2-power-free word. Splitting would help.
  • OWR-2090-006 bundles Linial's open-ended challenges on Latin squares and the Γ function with one precise conjecture (OWR 44/2008, p. 2496): the maximum rank of a real n×n×n tensor is (1+o(1))n²/2. That conjecture deserves its own record.
  • OWR-2090-026: the statement is clean (Problem 9, Barvinok–Samorodnitsky), but original_statement also contains Problem 10 (Welzl, spanning trees versus triangulations). That problem is already OWR-2090-027.

Garbled extracts (all already marked "unrecoverable", but still published as open or partially solved)

  • OWR-12861-024: the source itself is ill-posed (OWR 01/2014, p. 83). The matrix has rows indexed by S_n but columns only by {σ : LIS(σ) ≥ n−t}, and it is called both M and A, so its determinant is undefined.
  • OWR-9790358-007: the opening of Hakopian's abstract plus its title (OWR 7/2022, p. 405), with no question in it. Its only conjecture, Gasca–Maeztu, is OWR-9790358-001.
  • OWR-12697684-002, -003: table-of-contents lines (OWR 1/2023, pp. 9–10). -012: background sentences from Bucić's abstract (p. 42) about the Erdős–Hajnal conjecture, which is -011.
  • Also in OWR 1/2023: the "original OWR report" link of OWR-12697684-001, -002, -003, -011 and -012 points to 10.4171/owr/2022/57 (Enumerative Combinatorics). It should be 10.4171/owr/2023/1.
  • OWR-14298158-001: a table-of-contents entry (OWR 6/2024, p. 277). -016: the closing remark of an abstract on Bevan's conjecture (p. 299); the conjecture itself is -015.
  • OWR-723-001: Beck's four circle-discrepancy questions. The source itself reports them as answered, by Schmidt and by Beck (OWR 13/2004, pp. 678–679). The conjecture that remains is OWR-723-002. Mark solved or remove.

Misattached notes

  • OWR-2090-021: the note (parametric assignment, rotation matching) belongs to Rote's Problem 2 of the same session, least-squares matching under rotation (OWR 44/2008, pp. 2546–2547). The relevant literature for this record is Adiprasito–Björner (above).
  • OWR-4425-012: the note ("sum-square avoidance", Au–Robertson–Shallit) is about the additive-square problem, Problem 47, which is OWR-4425-018. The record itself is Shallit's Problem 38 on pattern characterisations of α-powers (OWR 37/2010, p. 2231).

— Alper Ferudun

Source and literature update for OWR-13674-017 (frozen v1.6.0). This is a correction/attribution notice, not a new authored solution.

Recent primary literature: the record's August 2026 “open” assessment predates Akbas–Sra, arXiv:2608.28816v1, whose Theorem 1.2 states the square Matrix Spencer result. Song–Zhang, arXiv:2609.15025v2 is another square-result preprint. Kathuria, arXiv:2609.18914v1, Theorem 1.1, states the rectangular bound C sqrt(N*(1+log(2d/N))) for N real symmetric d-by-d contractions with d >= N, and C sqrt(N) for d <= N. Here N counts matrices and d is dimension. These are attributed preprint claims; I checked their statements and parameter scope, not their full technical proofs.

Normalization: the original report, printed p. 964, displays sqrt(n)*sqrt(log(m/n)+1). The dataset instead has sqrt(n*log(m/n)+1). These are not uniformly equivalent. The source prose also refers to more matrices while its displayed sum retains n terms; input count and dimension should be stated separately.

Here is an elementary check of the misplaced additive term. For N a power of two, let H be a Sylvester Hadamard matrix. Use its N columns as diagonals of N matrices, adding one zero coordinate so d=N+1. Each is a real symmetric contraction. Every signing epsilon satisfies ||H epsilon||_2=N, hence discrepancy at least sqrt(N). But N*log((N+1)/N)+1 <= 2. Thus the frozen normalization cannot hold with a universal constant under the standard dimension interpretation.

A literal M>d-input interpretation also differs from the standard conjecture: in dimension d=2^k, the M=d(d+1)/2 tensor words in I, X, Z, J with an even number of skew-symmetric J factors are symmetric orthogonal matrices and Hilbert–Schmidt orthogonal. Here I is the two-by-two identity, X=[[0,1],[1,0]], Z=diag(1,-1), and J=[[0,1],[-1,0]]. Every signed sum has operator norm at least sqrt(M), contradicting scale sqrt(d*(1+log(M/d))) as d grows. This does not contradict the standard bound, which uses the number of inputs.

Hermitian dilation (and realification for complex inputs) preserves signed-sum norms, so symmetry restrictions can be handled with constant dimension factors. Please distinguish the corrected standard statement, the malformed normalization and the recent credited preprints. No new paper, novelty claim, formal verification or maintainer-approved status change is asserted here.

OWR-14299292-015 (Maglione: immediate descendants of the elliptic-curve groups G_{E,P}(F_p)): exactly when P has order 2, and the class sum is PORC

I have released an unrefereed preprint, Immediate Descendants of the Elliptic-Curve Groups of Maglione and Stanojkovski (Alper Ferudun, Mercury Software GmbH).

Question. J. Maglione, problem session of Oberwolfach Report 27/2025 (Computational Group Theory), pp. 1443–1444, with the definitions in Maglione's abstract (joint with M. Stanojkovski), pp. 1421–1422, and in Maglione–Stanojkovski, Algebra Number Theory 19 (2025). For p ≥ 5, E: y² = x³ + ax + b over F_p and P ∈ E(F_p) other than the origin, G_{E,P}(F_p) is a group of order p⁹, class 2 and exponent p. (Q1) For which pairs (E, P) is there a central extension 1 → Z/pZ → G → G_{E,P}(F_p) → 1 with G of class 3 and order p¹⁰ (the source's definition of an immediate descendant)? (Q2) Du Sautoy and Vaughan-Lee showed that for y² = x³ − x and P = (0,0) the number of immediate descendants is not PORC; Maglione adds that it would be remarkable if the sum of these numbers over the isomorphism classes of all the groups G_{E,P}(F_p) were PORC.

Result.

  • (Q1) G_{E,P}(F_p) has an immediate descendant if and only if P has order 2; otherwise it is terminal. For P of order 2 the nucleus has rank 2: there are descendants of orders p¹⁰ and p¹¹, and at order p¹⁰ of exponents p and p².
  • For P of order 2 the numbers of immediate descendants of order p¹⁰, of all exponents and of exponent p, are explicit functions of p, of e₃ = |E3| and of the order s ∈ {2, 4} of the stabilizer of P in Aut(E). For y² = x³ − x and P = (0,0) this recovers Theorem 1 of du Sautoy–Vaughan-Lee and gives the total number of descendants of order p¹⁰ (6780, 87328, 365098, 1451506 for p = 5, 7, 11, 13), which they had proved not to be PORC.
  • (Q2) Summed over the isomorphism classes, the number of immediate descendants of order p¹⁰ is PORC with modulus 72, with explicit polynomials, and the number of those of exponent p is PORC with modulus 12. The 3-torsion dependence cancels because the sum involves only the numbers of pairs (E, P) with a rational point of order 3, or with full rational 3-torsion, and these are counted by points on curves of genus 0 (Kubert's Tate normal form of level 6 and the curve w³ = 9c + 1). PORC is meant with rational coefficients, as in du Sautoy–Vaughan-Lee; the source does not specify the coefficients.

Credit. The question is Maglione's. The groups, their isomorphism classification (Theorem A) and the structure of their automorphism groups (Theorems 2.15, 5.6, 5.8) are due to Maglione and Stanojkovski, and the proofs use these results. The group of y² = x³ − x goes back to du Sautoy; its exponent-p count and the non-PORC results are due to du Sautoy and Vaughan-Lee (J. Algebra 361 (2012)), whose Lie-ring method the note follows. The note uses O'Brien's p-group generation, the Lazard correspondence and Kubert's normal form (re-proved in the note). What it adds is the criterion, the counts for all pairs with P of order 2, and the class sums.

What stays open. (Q2) if the immediate descendants of order p¹¹, which are immediate descendants in O'Brien's sense, are counted as well: the note records computed values for p = 5, 7, 11 only (obtained by two independent programs), and nothing is proved about them. The conjecture N_p = p² + p − gcd(p − 2, 3) + gcd(p − 1, 4) for the number of isomorphism classes (Conjecture 1 of the same problem session; Maglione–Stanojkovski, Conjecture 6.9) is not addressed. Fields F_q with q = p^e, e > 1, are not treated.

Sources we could not read: Kubert, Proc. London Math. Soc. (3) 33 (1976) (paywalled; the note proves the normal form it uses); Higman's papers of 1960; the journal versions of Maglione–Stanojkovski and du Sautoy–Vaughan-Lee (the arXiv versions were read); of S. Lee (2016), Vaughan-Lee (2017, 2018), Stanojkovski–Voll and O'Brien–Stanojkovski only the abstracts. The standard references O'Brien (1990), Lazard (1954), Khukhro (1998) and Silverman (2009) are cited for standard facts only and were not consulted.

Note on the record: its second sentence asks about "the total number of immediate descendants" without fixing their order; in the source the preceding sentence defines an immediate descendant as a group of order p¹⁰, and the note answers (Q2) in that sense. Otherwise the record's wording matches the source.

Suggested status: solved in the source's sense (both questions answered with the source's definition of an immediate descendant, a group of order p¹⁰; the variant of (Q2) that also counts the descendants of order p¹¹ remains open). The dataset currently labels the record open. The note is unrefereed and novelty is not certified.

Three independent AI-assisted verification runs re-derived the proofs line by line, compared the statements with the sources and tested them with separately written programs (the nucleus for all 3632 pairs with p ≤ 13, also at the group level in GAP; the automorphism groups by exhaustive search; the descendant counts for all 182 classes with P of order 2 and p ≤ 23, and again in a third model for p ≤ 13 and selected classes at p = 17, 19). Our literature search (arXiv, OpenAlex, zbMATH, Crossref, Semantic Scholar, web) found no earlier answer. This is AI-assisted, self-audited and unrefereed work, not independent human peer review or formal certification. No absolute-priority claim is made. Corrections and prior-work pointers are welcome. — Alper Ferudun, Mercury Software GmbH

Status follow-up 146: an Oberwolfach record answered in print (the Conlon–Lee conjecture on subdivisions)

  • The item was checked against the current dataset (commit d371ee9, release v1.8.0), against its source (Oberwolfach Report 19/2019) and against the cited paper, read on arXiv; publication data are from Crossref. The suggested change is in bold.

Answered in print (refereed)

  • OWR-16931-006 → solved; the dataset currently labels it partially solved. Source: D. Conlon (joint work with O. Janzer and J. Lee), Extremal numbers of subdivisions, Oberwolfach Report 19/2019 (Combinatorics, Probability and Computing), pp. 1124–1127, Conjecture 14 (Conlon–Lee): for every even k ≥ 2 and every graph H there is δ > 0 with ex(n, H^{k−1}) = O(n^{1+1/k−δ}), where H^{k−1} is obtained by replacing each edge of H by a path with k − 1 new internal vertices. The abstract proves this for bipartite H (Theorem 15) and gives the exponent 1 + 2/k − δ for every graph H (Theorem 16); the record's assessment says that the conjecture is proved only for bipartite graphs. O. Janzer, The extremal number of longer subdivisions, Bull. London Math. Soc. 53 (2021), no. 1, 108–118 (doi:10.1112/blms.12404; arXiv:1905.08001), Theorem 1.7: for every simple graph F and every even k ≥ 2 there is ε > 0 with ex(n, F^{k−1}) = O(n^{1+1/k−ε}), with the same convention (the k-subdivision replaces the edges by internally disjoint paths of length k + 1). The abstract of the paper states that it proves both conjectures of Conlon and Lee; the other one, Theorem 1.6, gives ex(n, F^{k−1}) = O(n^{1+1/k}) for every multigraph F. Read: the abstract in OWR 19/2019 (Theorem 12, Corollary 13, Conjecture 14, Theorems 15 and 16) and Section 1 of arXiv:1905.08001 (Conjectures 1.2 and 1.3, Theorems 1.4–1.7).

The item rests on a refereed paper whose statements we read; we did not check its proofs. This is an AI-assisted, self-audited check, not independent human peer review: we read the source and the cited statements and took publication data from Crossref. The suggested label is a suggestion. Corrections are welcome. — Alper Ferudun, Mercury Software GmbH

Status follow-up 147: 3 Oberwolfach records answered (one in a refereed paper, two in preprints), and notes on three assessments

  • Each item was checked against the current dataset (commit d371ee9, release v1.8.0), against its source (abstracts in the Oberwolfach Reports, cited by report number and page) and against the cited papers, read on arXiv; publication data are from Crossref. Theorem numbers follow the arXiv versions read. Suggested changes are in bold.

Answered in print (refereed)

  • OWR-4800-011 → solved (yes); the dataset currently labels it partially solved. Source: C. Stroppel (joint work with I. Frenkel and J. Sussan), Fractional Euler characteristics and 3j-symbols, Oberwolfach Report 10/2011 (Representation Theory of Quivers and Finite Dimensional Algebras, doi:10.4171/owr/2011/10), pp. 589–592. Section 1 of the abstract asks whether the tensor products V_{d₁} ⊗ ⋯ ⊗ V_{d_r} of finite-dimensional irreducible U_q(sl₂)-modules can be categorified. The record's question is Theorem 1 of the abstract (Section 2), put as a question: for 1 ≤ j ≤ n there is a finite-dimensional quasi-hereditary graded algebra A_{j,n} of finite global dimension whose category of graded modules has, up to isomorphism and grading shift, exactly C(n, j) simple objects, indexed by the {0, 1}-sequences of length n with exactly j ones; there is an isomorphism of ℤ[q, q⁻¹]-modules ⊕j K₀(A{j,n}-gmod) ≅ ⊕j V₁^{⊗n}(j) that sends standard modules to the standard basis and simple objects in degree zero to the dual canonical basis, and exact functors induce the U_q-action. The abstract bases this categorification on the following paper. I. Frenkel, M. Khovanov, C. Stroppel, A categorification of finite-dimensional irreducible representations of quantum sl₂ and their tensor products, Selecta Math. (N.S.) 12 (2006), no. 3–4, 379–431 (doi:10.1007/s00029-007-0031-y; arXiv:math/0511467). There ⁱA is the endomorphism algebra of a minimal projective generator of the block O{i;n} of category O(gl_n) whose integral weight has stabiliser S_i × S_{n−i}, with its Koszul grading (Section 3.2). The Verma modules M(a) and the simple modules L(a) of this block are indexed by the a ∈ {0, 1}ⁿ with exactly i ones (Section 2.2 and Theorem 5.3(e)), and the Verma modules are the standard modules of a block of O (Remark 2.5), so ⁱA is quasi-hereditary. Theorem 5.3(a): an isomorphism of U_q(sl₂)-modules from the (complexified) Grothendieck group of ⊕_{i=0}^n gmod-ⁱA to V₁^{⊗n}, sending the class of the graded Verma module M̃(a)⟨k⟩ to q^k v_a, with the action induced by exact functors E, F, K (Theorem 3.6). Theorem 5.3(e): graded Verma modules go to the standard basis, graded simple modules to the dual canonical basis and indecomposable tilting modules to the canonical basis. With A_{j,n} = ʲA this is the record's statement. The record's assessment speaks of a broader question, but the record asks only about V₁^{⊗n}(j); for arbitrary tensor products, Theorem 4.1 of the same paper (graded Harish-Chandra bimodules) gives an isomorphism of U_q(sl₂)-modules onto V_{d₁} ⊗ ⋯ ⊗ V_{d_r}. Our remark for the maintainers: the record turns a theorem of the abstract into a question; the problems that the abstract poses (p. 592) are to categorify the projections onto the summands of V_i ⊗ V_j and the 3j-symbols, and the abstract sketches answers to both. Read: the abstract in OWR 10/2011; the introduction, Sections 2.2, 3.1–3.2, 3.5 (Theorem 3.6), 4.1 (Theorem 4.1) and 5.2 (Theorem 5.3) of arXiv:math/0511467v1 (the journal version was not read).

Solved in preprints (labels → solved; preprints, not refereed)

  • OWR-8415355-003 → solved (yes; preprint, not refereed); the dataset currently labels it partially solved. Source: B. Davison, The perverse filtration on the preprojective stack and the enveloping algebra of the BPS Lie algebra, Oberwolfach Report 52/2021 (Enveloping Algebras and Geometric Representation Theory, doi:10.4171/owr/2021/52), pp. 2831–2834. For a finite quiver Q, Theorem 1 there identifies a subalgebra L₀A_{Π_Q} of the preprojective CoHA A_{Π_Q} with U(g_{Q̃,W̃}), the enveloping algebra of the BPS Lie algebra of the tripled quiver with potential, and gives a Lie algebra object g_{Π_Q} in perverse sheaves on the coarse moduli space with H(g_{Π_Q}) ≅ g_{Q̃,W̃}. Theorem 3: if there is a simple d-dimensional Π_Q-module, then g_{Π_Q,d} ≅ IC_{X_d}(ℚ_vir) ⊕ C canonically, and the Lie bracket into degree d factors through C, so IC(X_d) is a canonical subspace of a space of primitive generators in degree d. The author conjectures that IC(X_d) is a complete space of primitive degree-d generators. Yes: B. Davison, L. Hennecart, S. Schlegel Mejia, BPS algebras and generalised Kac–Moody algebras from 2-Calabi–Yau categories, preprint arXiv:2303.12592 (v5, November 2025). Theorem 1.1 (for 2-Calabi–Yau categories as in §4; Rep(Π_Q) of any quiver is among the main examples): the (ψ-twisted) BPS algebra sheaf is U(n⁺), where n⁺ is the free Lie algebra object on G = ⊕ G_d modulo generalised Serre relations (§§1.1.2, 3.2). Here G_d = IC(M_{Π_Q,d}) for d ∈ Σ_{Π_Q}, where M_{Π_Q,d} is the coarse moduli space X_d of the abstract, and G_{lδ} = (u_{lδ})*IC(M{Π_Q,δ}) for isotropic δ ∈ Σ_{Π_Q} and l ≥ 2 (§6.4, Proposition 6.9). By Lemma 5.1 and Crawley-Boevey's theorem, Σ_{Π_Q} is exactly the set of dimension vectors of simple Π_Q-modules. Proposition 8.4 (Theorem 1.17) identifies this Lie algebra with the 3D BPS Lie algebra: n^{BPS,+}{Π_Q} ≅ g^ψ{Q̃,W̃}. The Serre relations are brackets of generators, so n⁺d = G_d ⊕ [n⁺, n⁺]d; hence, for every d for which a simple d-dimensional Π_Q-module exists, the primitive generators in degree d are exactly IC(X_d) (our one-line deduction; we found no mention of the conjecture in the paper). We found no journal version (arXiv, Crossref, OpenAlex). Our remarks for the maintainers: in the source the generators are those of the BPS Lie algebra g{Q̃,W̃}, whose enveloping algebra is the subalgebra L₀A{Π_Q}, not of the whole CoHA A_{Π_Q} as the record says; and the record omits the hypothesis of Theorem 3. Without it the statement fails: for d = 2·1_i at a vertex i without loops, X_d is a point, so IC(X_d) ≠ 0, but the only representation of Q of dimension vector d is decomposable, so the Kac polynomial a_{Q,d} vanishes and, by Theorem 1(4) of the abstract, so does g_{Π_Q,d} (our remark). Read: the abstract in OWR 52/2021; §§1.1–1.2, 1.6, 3.1–3.2, 5.1, 6.4 and 8.1–8.2 of arXiv:2303.12592v5 (not the proofs of §7).
  • OWR-11101920-002 → solved (yes; preprint, not refereed); the dataset currently labels it partially solved. Source: N. Libedinsky (joint work with L. Patimo, D. Plaza and G. Williamson), Some aspects of Kazhdan–Lusztig polynomials, Oberwolfach Report 39/2022 (Character Theory and Categorification, doi:10.4171/owr/2022/39), pp. 2273–2274, problem (1). It concerns the pre-canonical bases N^i_λ of the spherical Hecke algebra (λ dominant, i a positive integer) from N. Libedinsky, L. Patimo, D. Plaza, Pre-canonical bases on affine Hecke algebras, Adv. Math. 399 (2022) 108255 (doi:10.1016/j.aim.2022.108255): for i = 1 they form the standard basis and for large i the Kazhdan–Lusztig basis. The abstract conjectures that in affine type A the expansion of N^{i+1}λ in the N^i_μ is positive. The record writes N{λ_{i+1}} and N_{μ_i} for N^{i+1}λ and N^i_μ. Yes: D. Plaza, Y. Sagurie, Positivity of pre-canonical bases for spherical Hecke algebras, preprint arXiv:2608.07703 (v1, 7 August 2026). Conjecture A there, attributed to the Adv. Math. paper: for the root system of type A_n, with its affine Weyl group and spherical Hecke algebra, if N^{i+1}λ = Σ_μ a^i{μ,λ}(q) N^i_μ, then a^i{μ,λ}(q) ∈ ℤ_{≥0}[q] for all dominant λ, μ and all i ≥ 2. Theorem C proves it and gives a combinatorial algorithm for the a^i_{μ,λ}(q); the proof is Theorem 7.20 (Theorem E of the introduction), by repeated use of Theorem 7.19 (Theorem D). For i = 1 the expansion is positive already: N² is the atomic basis (the anti-atomic formula, Theorem 3.1 of the Adv. Math. paper, as quoted there), and (1.2) there expands it in the standard basis with coefficients q^{ht(λ−μ)}, μ ≤ λ (our remark). We found no journal version (arXiv, Crossref). Our remark for the maintainers: the record's list of sources labels the Adv. Math. paper "Patimo–Plaza–Williamson"; by Crossref and the report's reference list its authors are Libedinsky, Patimo and Plaza. Read: the abstract in OWR 39/2022; §§1–2 and the statements of Theorems 7.19 and 7.20 of arXiv:2608.07703v1 (we did not check the proofs, and we did not read the Adv. Math. paper).

Notes on three records (labels unchanged)

  • OWR-824-003 → partially solved, with the conjecture proved in print (the label stays partially solved; please update the assessment and the second sentence of the statement). Source: A. Conca, Products of linear spaces, polymatroids and integral posets, Oberwolfach Report 19/2005 (Kommutative Algebra), pp. 1087–1090. The conjecture on p. 1089 is for an m × n matrix L with L_ij = Σ_k a_ijk t_ik: for every choice of the a_ijk and every term order, the initial ideal of the ideal I₂(L) of 2-minors should be generated by monomials t_{i1j1}···t_{ikjk} with i1 < ··· < ik. The abstract proves it for generic L, and the record's assessment treats that case as the known one. A. Conca, E. De Negri, E. Gorla, Universal Gröbner bases and Cartwright–Sturmfels ideals, Int. Math. Res. Not. IMRN 2020, no. 7, 1979–1991 (doi:10.1093/imrn/rny075; arXiv:1608.08942), Main Theorem (3)–(4) and Corollary 1.19: for every row-graded matrix of linear forms A, the ideal I₂(A) is Cartwright–Sturmfels; every initial ideal of it is radical, and it has a universal Gröbner basis of elements of multidegree ≤ (1,…,1). Conca's L is row graded (row i has degree e_i), so this is the conjecture; for m > n one applies the column-graded case to the transpose, and the paper's assumption that the field is infinite costs nothing, since reduced Gröbner bases do not change under field extension (our remarks). In the source, the record's second sentence ("Does the same statement hold for every distributive lattice?") follows the sentence that every rank truncation of a hypercube is an integral poset; the open question there is whether every rank truncation of a distributive lattice is integral, i.e. supports a homogeneous ASL domain. We found no answer to it. Read: the abstract in OWR 19/2005; the introduction (Main Theorem) and Section 1 of arXiv:1608.08942v1 (the journal version was not read).
  • OWR-1790-003 (label partially solved, unchanged): the assessment could say that the record's yes/no sub-question is answered in its own source. By Corollary 3.3 of R. J. Marsh's abstract in Oberwolfach Report 9/2008 (A. B. Buan, R. J. Marsh, I. Reiten, J. London Math. Soc. (2) 79 (2009) 589–611, doi:10.1112/jlms/jdn082, Corollary 1.7), every cluster variable has a T-denominator for every cluster-tilting object T if and only if Q is Dynkin or has two vertices, and Example 7.2 of that paper is an explicit failure in type Ã₂ (we checked the example). The general question of interpreting denominators for non-acyclic seeds is called open in the source.
  • OWR-3480-003 (label partially solved, unchanged): the assessment does not cite the main later result. F. Andreatta, E. Z. Goren, B. Howard, K. Madapusi Pera, Height pairings on orthogonal Shimura varieties, Compositio Math. 153 (2017) 474–534 (doi:10.1112/S0010437X1600779X), Theorem A, prove the conjectured formula of Bruinier and Yang for maximal lattices L (n ≥ 1) and CM cycles with C⁺(L₀) the maximal order of an imaginary quadratic field of odd discriminant; non-maximal lattices and other CM planes are not covered, as far as we found.

The item on OWR-4800-011 rests on a refereed paper whose statements we read; we did not check its proofs. The two items under the preprint heading rest on preprints that have not been refereed, so the maintainers may prefer to treat them under the dataset's policy for unrefereed claims (partially solved, evidence unrefereed_claim). The notes concern literature assessments only; the labels stay as they are. The remarks marked as ours are one-line deductions and have not been refereed. These are AI-assisted, self-audited checks, not independent human peer review: for each item we read the source and the cited statements and took publication data from Crossref. The suggested labels are suggestions. Corrections are welcome. — Alper Ferudun, Mercury Software GmbH

AMR-022-1032 — quantitative refinement, not a new closure of the original problem

New preprint: Iterated-Logarithmic Size of Gross Exceptional Sets (Alper Ferudun, Mercury Software GmbH).

For every q>1, the paper constructs one transcendental entire function and one regular inverse germ with a compact subset of exceptional directions of positive finite Hausdorff h_q measure, where h_q(t)=t[log log(e^e/t)]^q. Along every direction in that compact set, the same inverse branch escapes at unit radius. In that single example the compact set has infinite measure for every gauge t[log(e/t)]^epsilon, epsilon>0.

Prior work and scope: Sina Nadi's arXiv:2609.29797v1 already gives the positive-capacity counterexample, and Eremenko's live problem index attributes dimension one to Nadi. Both are credited; neither is claimed as new. Our claim is the explicit iterated-logarithmic gauge refinement, using slowly varying corridors, a nonatomic Bernoulli shell sum and an exponential holomorphic approximation weight. We do not settle q=1, identify the entire exceptional set with our compact subset, or classify all exceptional sets. This adds zero new original-source or exact-question closures.

Six-page English proof, source ZIP and reproducibility report:

The package contains 16,878 supporting exact/symbolic and high-precision regression checks, including negative controls. They supplement the written analytic proof and are not a formal proof. This AI-assisted, self-audited preprint is unrefereed; no independent review or certified absolute priority is claimed. This is a public research report, not a maintainer-approved dataset update.

AIM-ANALYSIS-0071 — counterexample to the uniform even-phase Carleson bound near exponent zero

New preprint: Failure of Uniform Bounds for Fractional Carleson Operators at Exponent Zero (Alper Ferudun, Mercury Software GmbH).

Let C_epsilon f(x) = sup_{lambda in R} |p.v. integral_R f(x-t) exp(i lambda |t|^epsilon) dt/t|. For every integer N>=1 and 0<epsilon<=2^(-16-12N), we prove

||C_epsilon||_{L2 -> L2} >= sqrt(3N/(2048*pi)).

In particular, for 0<epsilon<=2^(-56), the norm is at least sqrt(log_2(1/epsilon)/(16384*pi)). Thus the constant cannot be uniform as epsilon decreases to zero, also when the proposed inequality is restricted to compactly supported smooth inputs.

This is a negative answer to Guo's Question 12, equation (0.17), page 4 of the AIM workshop report Carleson theorems and multilinear operators. The same even-phase uniformity question appears as (1.15) in Question 1.4 of Guo's https://arxiv.org/abs/1503.04411. Fixed-exponent boundedness and uniform estimates away from the exceptional exponents are compatible with the lower bound. The original AIM PDF URL currently returns 404; we checked the preserved primary PDF downloaded on 6 October, with its provenance and SHA-256 recorded in the package.

The frozen UnsolvedMath report already gives the logarithmic-phase reduction and its multiplier; both are credited. The added argument uses a finite-valued base-16 digit selector to align packets centered at exp(16^j), followed by an explicit small/middle/large-region kernel estimate transferring the lower bound to positive exponents. The equivalent AIM and Guo formulations are one question, not two new closures. This paper does not address the odd-phase question near exponent one or determine optimal norm growth.

Six-page English proof, source ZIP and verification report:

The 153,218 supporting exact and high-precision checks supplement the analytic all-N proof; they are not formal verification. AI-assisted, self-audited and unrefereed; no independent review or certified absolute priority is claimed. This concerns frozen v1.6.0, commit c6e7f41b4eb6ce876feb83e7eb626be1b243fd7e. It is a public research report and does not imply maintainer acceptance or a dataset edit.

Status follow-up 148: the open case A₅(0) of an Oberwolfach record follows from published results (cohomology of connected Hopf algebras of dimension p³)

  • The item was checked against the current dataset (commit d371ee9, release v1.8.0), against its source (Oberwolfach Report 11/2019) and against the cited papers, read on arXiv; publication data are from Crossref. The suggested change is in bold.

A sub-question answered by a short deduction from published results (the deduction is ours, not refereed)

  • OWR-16773-005 → partially solved, with the A₅(0) case answered yes (the label stays partially solved; please update the assessment); the dataset currently labels it partially solved. Source: Oberwolfach Report 11/2019 (Mini-Workshop: Cohomology of Hopf Algebras and Tensor Categories), pp. 663–693. The record asks whether the cohomology of every finite-dimensional noncocommutative Hopf algebra is finitely generated and, in particular, whether finite generation holds, for odd p, for the remaining algebra A₅(0) among the connected Hopf algebras of dimension p³. K. Erdmann's abstract (p. 682, Example 2) gives A₅(β) = k⟨y, z⟩/(y^p, a^p, [a, y], [a, z], z^p + a^{p−1}y − βa), a = yz − zy, as the family left open by K. Erdmann, Ø. Solberg, X. Wang, J. Algebra 527 (2019) 366–398 (doi:10.1016/j.jalgebra.2019.02.030), and settles β ≠ 0 (arXiv:1904.04533). Our deduction: with x = [y, z], A₅(β) is the Hopf algebra A(β) of type (A5) in V. C. Nguyen, L. Wang, X. Wang, Classification of connected Hopf algebras of dimension p³ I, J. Algebra 424 (2015) 473–505 (arXiv:1309.0286), Theorem 1.1, and Remark 1.5 there states that the types (A1)–(A5) are cocommutative (the printed coproduct of (A5) is symmetric). A finite-dimensional cocommutative Hopf algebra is the group algebra of a finite group scheme, so E. M. Friedlander, A. Suslin, Cohomology of finite group schemes over a field, Invent. Math. 127 (1997) 209–270 (doi:10.1007/s002220050119), Theorem 1.1, shows that H*(A₅(β), k) = Ext*_{A₅(β)}(k, k) is finitely generated, and that Ext*(M, N) is a finitely generated module over it for finite-dimensional modules M and N, for every odd p, every field of characteristic p and every β. This ring depends only on the algebra, which is local, and not on the Hopf structure. Erdmann, Solberg and Wang use the same theorem for three other types (Section 11.4) and work with the algebra structure only (Section 2.3). The group-scheme interpretation of A(β) also appears in C. Liedtke, G. Martin, Y. Matsumoto, arXiv:2110.03650 (Astérisque 461 (2025) according to the arXiv record), Proposition 3.7 and Remark 3.8, which do not discuss cohomology. X. Wang's abstract in the same report (p. 686) states, without an argument, that finite generation holds for all connected Hopf algebras of dimension at most p³. Our checks: a second, explicit cocommutative coproduct on A₅(β) (y primitive, Δ(z) = z ⊗ 1 + 1 ⊗ z + Σ_{i=1}^{p−1} (C(p,i)/p) y^i ⊗ y^{p−i}), proved for every odd p and verified by computer for p ≤ 11, together with NWW's coproduct for p ≤ 7; for β = 0, the identification of A₅(0) with the group algebra of the group scheme with O(G) = F_p[x, c]/(x^{p²}, c^p) and (x, c)(x′, c′) = (x + x′, c + c′ − x x′^p), verified for p ≤ 7; and the dimensions of Ext^n_{A₅(0)}(k, k) for p = 3 (n ≤ 20), p = 5 (n ≤ 10) and p = 7 (n ≤ 7), computed by two independent programs. Our remark for the maintainers: the record files A₅(0) under noncocommutative Hopf algebras, but by NWW it is cocommutative; the general question (finite generation for every finite-dimensional Hopf algebra, the conjecture of Etingof and Ostrik) stays open. Read: the abstracts of Erdmann, Solberg and Wang in OWR 11/2019; Theorem 1.1, Remark 1.5 and Theorem 3.2 of arXiv:1309.0286; Sections 2.3, 8 and 11.4 of the arXiv version of the paper of Erdmann, Solberg and Wang; the introduction and Section 6 of arXiv:1904.04533; Proposition 3.7 and Remark 3.8 of arXiv:2110.03650v2. Not read: the original paper of Friedlander and Suslin (its Theorem 1.1 as quoted by Erdmann, Solberg and Wang, Section 11.4) and the journal versions.

The deduction marked as ours takes two lines and has not been refereed; the maintainers may prefer to treat it under the dataset's policy for unrefereed claims. These are AI-assisted, self-audited checks, not independent human peer review: we read the source and the cited statements and took publication data from Crossref. The suggested label is a suggestion. Corrections are welcome. — Alper Ferudun, Mercury Software GmbH

OWR-1738-006 (Hertweck: partial augmentations at π(u) in Z GL_n(k), Problem 9): no as printed, by an elementary unit of Bovdi's kind; the restricted readings remain open

I have released an unrefereed preprint, Partial Augmentations in Integral Group Rings of GL_n(k): Hertweck's Question Fails as Printed for n ≥ char k; the Restricted Questions Remain Open (Alper Ferudun, Mercury Software GmbH).

Question. M. Hertweck, Problem 9 of the problem list in Oberwolfach Report 55/2007 (Mini-Workshop "Arithmetik von Gruppenringen", page printed 3172; 3232 in the pagination 3209–3240 of the metadata): for G = GL_n(k), k a finite field, and π: V(ZG) → G the surjective homomorphism induced by the embedding G ⊆ M_n(k), is the partial augmentation ε_{π(u)}(u) nonzero for every torsion unit u of V(ZG)? The printed question restricts neither n, nor k, nor the order of u. The record also contains Problems 8 and 10 of the same list (Hertweck: the modular isomorphism problem for p-groups with a normal complement; conjugacy of the units u_p built from central primitive idempotents); the note does not treat them.

Result (as printed: no).

  • For every finite field k of characteristic p and every n ≥ p, the element u = x + (x − 1)h x̂, with x = I + E_12 + … + E_{p−1,p}, x̂ = 1 + x + … + x^{p−1} and h the signed transposition of e_1 and e_p, is a unit of order p in V(Z GL_n(k)) with ε_{π(u)}(u) = 0: all powers of u have the partial augmentations of the powers of x, while π(u) = I + E_12 + … + E_{p−2,p−1} has Jordan type (p − 1, 1^{n−p+1}). The unit is conjugate to x in QG, but in Z_pG it is conjugate to no element of G.
  • The smallest case is the five-term unit u = x + xh + xhx − h − hx of order 2 in Z S_3 = Z GL_2(2), with π(u) = 1. The example is elementary and settles only the question as printed. For u_h = x + (x − 1)h x̂ with arbitrary h, ε_{π(u_h)}(u_h) = 0 exactly when h_{p1} = −1; for n < p no unit of Bovdi's types is a counterexample.

Partial results for the readings that were probably intended, (R1) units of order prime to p and (R2) n < char k:

  • units of order prime to p that are rationally conjugate to group elements have ε_{π(u)}(u) = 1 (a known argument, Hertweck's preprint, Remark 3.3), so a counterexample to (R1) would also be a counterexample to the first Zassenhaus conjecture (ZC1) for GL_n(k);
  • GL_2(p), p odd: for every unit u of order p, π(u) is a nontrivial unipotent element, so ε_{π(u)}(u) = 1; for GL_2(p) the question therefore reduces to units of order prime to p;
  • GL_2(q): units of order 2 (q odd) and of odd prime order dividing q + 1;
  • all torsion units of Z GL_2(3) and Z GL_2(5), by the published proofs of (ZC1).

Credit. The question is Hertweck's. The counterexamples are units of the kind V. Bovdi considered in Problem 4 of the same list, where their rational conjugacy is remarked. The tools for the positive results come from Hertweck's preprint "Partial augmentations and Brauer character values of torsion units in group rings" (arXiv:math/0612429v2; the report lists it as to appear in Comm. Algebra, but no published version was found), whose two results used here are proved in the note, and from Hertweck, Algebra Colloq. 13 (2006); the result on GL_2(p) is the simplest case of the lattice method of Bächle and Margolis (Proc. Edinb. Math. Soc. 60 (2017)). The (ZC1) results used are Bovdi–Hertweck, J. Group Theory 11 (2008), Example 2 (GL(2,5)), and Bächle–Herman–Konovalov–Margolis–Singh, Exp. Math. 27 (2018) (all groups of order less than 144). Compare Eisele–Margolis, Rev. Mat. Complut. 38 (2025), Theorem 1.2, for units of order p when the Sylow p-subgroup has order p.

What stays open. (R1) and (R2) in general, for example units of order p in GL_2(p^f) with p odd and f ≥ 2 (first case GL_2(9)), units of order p in GL_n(p) with 3 ≤ n < p (first case GL_3(5)), and units of order prime to p outside the cases above in groups for which (ZC1) is not known, such as units of order 3 in GL_2(7) and of order 4 in GL_2(p), p ≥ 7. Problems 8 and 10 of the record are not treated.

Sources we could not read: W. Kimmerle's surveys in Jahresber. Dtsch. Math.-Ver. 115 (2013) (closed access) and Int. J. Group Theory (2015) (dead link); Bächle–Kimmerle, J. Algebra 326 (2011) (access refused); Gildea's papers on particular simple groups. Marciniak–Ritter–Sehgal–Weiss (1987), Hertweck (2006), Bächle–Margolis (2017), Eisele–Margolis (2018) and the classical papers of Cohn–Livingstone, Higman and Osima are cited for their statements as described in the sources read; the proofs of (ZC1) for GL_2(3) and GL_2(5) were not checked beyond their statements.

Note on the record: it combines Problems 8, 9 and 10 of the list; its second sentence is a faithful paraphrase of Problem 9.

Suggested status: partially solved (unchanged): Problem 9 is answered no only as printed, by an elementary example; its restricted readings and Problems 8 and 10 remain open. The note is unrefereed, novelty is not certified, and the contribution is modest.

Three independent AI-assisted verification runs re-derived the proofs line by line, compared the statements with the sources and tested them with separately written programs (exact group-ring computations of the counterexamples for many pairs (n, q), exhaustive checks of the criterion over all h in small groups, a search of torsion units in Z S_3, Brauer characters and decomposition numbers of GL_2(p) for small p). Our literature search (arXiv, Crossref, OpenAlex, Semantic Scholar, zbMATH, web) found no earlier discussion of the question. This is AI-assisted, self-audited and unrefereed work, not independent human peer review or formal certification. No absolute-priority claim is made. Corrections and prior-work pointers are welcome. — Alper Ferudun, Mercury Software GmbH

Sign up or log in to comment