amphora's picture
v2: add 216 optimize tasks / 77 families (Tao constants, AlphaEvolve, Leaps in Bounds, FrontierShift, FrontierCO MDS, ALE-Bench, FrontierCS, EdgeBench)
ac7c4a9 verified
|
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
14.8 kB
---
license: other
license_name: mixed
license_link: LICENSE.md
configs:
- config_name: construct
data_files: data/construct.parquet
- config_name: optimize
data_files: data/optimize.parquet
tags:
- math
- reinforcement-learning
- rl-environment
- verifiable-rewards
- harbor
size_categories:
- 1K<n<10K
---
# MathConstructOptimize-Envs
**3,793 RL tasks in 219 families where the model must *construct a mathematical object*, graded by a deterministic checker.** There is no answer matching and no LLM judge in the reward path.
Most math RL data asks for a final number. Here the model has to produce the object itself: a colouring, a design, a counterexample, a point configuration, a polynomial. The checker accepts **any** valid object, not a stored answer. The collection has two subsets:
| subset | what the model does | reward | families | tasks |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| `construct` | produce any object satisfying stated conditions (a witness) | 1 if valid, else 0 | 80 | 3,464 |
| `optimize` | produce a valid object with the best objective it can (extremal constructions, bound improvement) | 0 if invalid; otherwise 0.1 + 0.9 × progress from a trivial baseline to the best known value | 139 | 329 |
The runnable sandboxed version (one [Harbor](https://github.com/laude-institute/harbor) task directory per row) is in
[`amphora/MathConstructOptimize-Envs-harbor`](https://huggingface.co/datasets/amphora/MathConstructOptimize-Envs-harbor).
## Sources
Tasks are converted from existing generator suites and research-problem repositories. Each checker was re-implemented and hardened; see the list of upstream verifier bugs below.
| source | subset | tier | families | tasks |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| [RLVE-Gym](https://github.com/Zhiyuan-Zeng/RLVE) | construct | competition | 30 | 1,800 |
| [MathConstraint](https://github.com/vireshpati/Math-Constraint) | construct | competition | 33 | 875 |
| [NPPC](https://github.com/SMU-DIGA/nppc) | construct | competition | 8 | 480 |
| [Reasoning Gym](https://github.com/open-thought/reasoning-gym) | construct | competition | 3 | 180 |
| [AlphaEvolve repository of problems](https://github.com/google-deepmind/alphaevolve_repository_of_problems) | construct + optimize | research (mostly) | 34 | 203 |
| [EinsteinArena](https://einsteinarena.com) | optimize | research | 26 | 28 |
| [FunSearch](https://github.com/google-deepmind/funsearch) | optimize | research | 3 | 15 |
| [Finch / Evolution Fine-Tuning](https://github.com/Open-Galapagos/evolution-fine-tuning) (`erdos_*` tasks) | optimize | research / competition | 12 | 12 |
| [Optimization Constants in Mathematics](https://github.com/teorth/optimizationproblems) (Tao, Davis, Ivanisvili) | optimize | research | 13 | 17 |
| [Leaps in Bounds](https://leapsinbounds.org) (D. Munro) | optimize | research | 14 | 82 |
| [FrontierShift open problems](https://aitonomy.org/projects/open-problems) (AItonomy Foundation) | optimize | research | 8 | 9 |
| [FrontierCO](https://huggingface.co/datasets/CO-Bench/FrontierCO) (minimum dominating set only) | optimize | competition | 1 | 15 |
| [ALE-Bench](https://huggingface.co/datasets/SakanaAI/ALE-Bench) (AtCoder Heuristic Contest) | optimize | competition | 18 | 36 |
| [FrontierCS](https://github.com/FrontierCS/Frontier-CS) (algorithmic track) | optimize | competition | 14 | 37 |
| [EdgeBench](https://github.com/ByteDance-Seed/EdgeBench) (released task dirs) | optimize | competition | 2 | 4 |
Construct generators have 4–6 difficulty levels × 10 seeds. Optimize tasks are single research problems or contest instances, some at several sizes *n*. Sources added in v2 (2026-11-18) are described in the v2 section below. `families.csv` lists every family with its source, license, domain, `problem_key` and tags.
## Row schema
| column | meaning |
|---|---|
| `task_id` | unique id |
| `subset`, `family`, `problem_key` | task contract, generator family, canonical math problem id (for cross-source dedupe) |
| `domain`, `tier`, `level` | math area, `competition` or `research`, difficulty level |
| `source`, `license` | upstream task and its license |
| `tags` | see below |
| `prompt` | full, self-contained task statement including the required JSON answer schema |
| `instance` | JSON string with the instance data the checker needs |
| `direction`, `baseline`, `best_known` | optimize only: objective direction, trivial-baseline score, best known score |
| `reference_answer`, `reference_reward` | a known valid answer (planted witness or published construction) and its reward; for SFT/debugging, not needed for grading |
## Grading
```python
from datasets import load_dataset
from huggingface_hub import snapshot_download
import sys, json
repo = snapshot_download("amphora/MathConstructOptimize-Envs", repo_type="dataset", allow_patterns=["grade.py", "graders/*"])
sys.path.insert(0, repo)
from grade import grade
ds = load_dataset("amphora/MathConstructOptimize-Envs", "construct", split="train")
row = ds[0]
reward, details = grade(row, json.loads(row["reference_answer"])) # -> 1.0, {"valid": True}
```
Graders need Python ≥ 3.10 with numpy, scipy, sympy and networkx. Every check runs in under 60 s. Feasibility checks use exact integer or rational arithmetic wherever the problem allows.
The **optimize reward** is `0` for an invalid answer, else `0.1 + 0.9 · clip(progress, 0, 1)`. Progress is linear between `baseline` (a deliberately weak valid construction) and `best_known`. The kissing-number tasks use a log scale of the overlap loss instead. The 0.1 floor for validity keeps GRPO groups from being all-zero, because without it research-level tasks gave no signal in our pilot.
## Tags
| tag | meaning |
|---|---|
| `agentic_trivial` | a solver (CP-SAT, z3, brute force) cracks the top level within seconds, so the task is useful single-turn but weak for sandboxed agents (2,368 tasks) |
| `np_search` | the task is essentially combinatorial search |
| `best_known_uncertain` | `best_known` comes from our own search or an uncited value |
| `ea_under_review` | EinsteinArena marks the problem as under review. We audited each one and included it only when we could make the check sound |
| `unique_answer` | the answer is unique, but it is still verified as a witness (e.g. by expanding a factorization) |
| `float_objective`, `exact_integer`, `exact_rational`, ... | how the objective is computed |
| `reference_is_baseline` / `reference_below_record` | the shipped `reference_answer` is the weak baseline (reward 0.1) or a valid construction weaker than `best_known` |
| `known_optimum` | `best_known` is a proved optimum, so the reward cannot exceed 1 by improving it |
| `record_memorizable` | the record object is famous; an agent that recalls it saturates the reward |
| `license_restricted` | source license restricts derivatives (ALE-Bench, CC BY-ND 4.0) |
| `license_unknown` | the source states no license (FrontierShift) |
## Reference pass rates (pilot, 66 tasks)
Pilot with 8 single-turn samples and 4 agentic attempts per task (Harbor `terminus-2`, no network):
| model / mode | trivial (≥0.9) | trainable | too hard (≤0.1) |
|---|---|---|---|
| gpt-oss-120b, single-turn | 23 | 23 | 20 |
| gpt-oss-120b, agentic | 33 | 19 | 13 |
| Qwen3-8B, single-turn | 13 | 15 | 38 |
| Qwen3-8B, agentic | 8 | 10 | 47 |
Pass rates vary a lot by model and mode, so filter for your policy. Difficulty levels are monotone within every generator family.
## Upstream verifier bugs found and fixed
Re-implementing the checkers surfaced problems in the source verifiers that an RL policy could exploit:
- **Model output executed as code.** RLVE `integral` (`sympify`) and Reasoning Gym integration (`parse_expr`) evaluate the model's answer as Python, and they also accept an unevaluated `Integral(f, x)`. Our checkers parse through a whitelist syntax tree.
- **Empty answers accepted.** MathConstraint `verify()` lets the solver fill in any variable the answer omits, so `{}` passes.
- **Missing range, length or type checks.**
- NPPC 3-colouring accepts an all-distinct colouring.
- Clique and independent set accept a vertex repeated k times.
- Quadratic congruence accepts x = 0.
- Several verifiers accept floats or bools.
- **Floating-point feasibility checks.**
- EinsteinArena circle packing and circles-in-rectangle (the AlphaEvolve seed overlaps by about 1e-16).
- Heilbronn triangle containment (uses a rounded √3).
- Finch tolerances that allowed beating the proven 10/3 bound.
- AlphaEvolve p58 (Erdős–Szekeres): the published 33- and 65-point sets reported as having no convex 7- or 8-gon **do contain one** under exact arithmetic.
- **Checks that are wrong or too weak.**
- AlphaEvolve spherical designs: the pass test compares a negated error, so it always passes.
- AlphaEvolve 3D Kakeya ignores tubes that leave its Monte Carlo box.
- Arithmetic Kakeya "repairs" the submitted distribution before scoring it.
- The prime-number-theorem constraint was checked on random samples.
- The uncertainty-principle root scan could miss roots.
- **Wrong or unreachable targets.** Several Finch targets are above a provable maximum, below a known optimum, or infeasible.
## Excluded
- AlphaEvolve problem 6: the notebook's functional differs from the one a construction-checker can certify.
- Problems with no checkable objective (proof-only or meta problems), or no recoverable construction or verifier.
- FunSearch corner-free sets (checker not released).
- Sources without a license (v1). v2 includes FrontierShift, which states no license, tagged `license_unknown`.
- Duplicate problem and size pairs across sources (deduplicated by `problem_key`).
## v2 (2026-11-18): optimize extension
216 new optimize tasks in 77 families (the `construct` subset is unchanged; the previous version is git tag `pre-v2`). Same reward contract and graders interface; every reference answer was re-graded in an isolated copy of the task's `tests/` dir, through `grade.py`, and by the Harbor oracle agent in the sandbox image; a no-op answer scores 0 everywhere. All checks run in under 10 s.
| source | families | tasks | license | notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Optimization Constants in Mathematics | 13 | 17 | Apache-2.0 | one family per constant where a finite object certifies a bound (Lehmer/Mahler measure, degree vs sensitivity, Komlós discrepancy, matrix-multiplication exponent from exact small-format algorithms, biplanar chromatic number, Bohnenblust–Hille, Berry–Esseen, Brezis–Gallouet–Wainger, sunflower-free families, Fourier entropy–influence, hollow lattice width, narrowest admissible tuples, covering systems) |
| AlphaEvolve repository (new problems/sizes) | 7 | 16 | CC-BY-4.0 | 2D Nikodym over F_{p²}, Hausdorff–Young, Thomson n=292/306, hexagons in a hexagon, Erdős discrepancy C=3, Szemerédi–Trotter incidences, Rudin L4/L2 spherical harmonics |
| Leaps in Bounds | 14 | 82 | MIT | cages, degree–diameter, superpermutations, snake/coil-in-the-box, Golomb rulers, no-three-in-line, sorting-network size/depth, equal circles in a square/triangle, isosceles sets, unit squares in a square, disk covering |
| FrontierShift | 8 | 9 | **unknown** | matrix-multiplication rank 3×3/4×4 over Q, max-determinant ±1 23×23, Boolean nonlinearity n=9, low-weight codeword (decoding challenge n=1280), abc quality, Cramér–Shanks–Granville gap ratio, rational Diophantine septuples, tetrahedra packing density |
| FrontierCO | 1 | 15 | MIT | minimum dominating set only (the other 7 types overlap CO-Bench) |
| ALE-Bench | 18 | 36 | **CC BY-ND 4.0** | non-interactive AtCoder Heuristic Contest problems, 2 public-seed instances each; statements kept verbatim; scorers re-implemented in Python and matched against the official tools on ~7,700 outputs |
| FrontierCS | 14 | 37 | MIT | algorithmic-track problems with deterministic scorers (Max-Cut, Max-3-SAT, Zarankiewicz grids, XOR-Sidon sets, ...); each port matched the upstream checker on ≥100 outputs |
| EdgeBench | 2 | 4 | CC-BY-4.0 | the two released task directories that run offline (AHC056, AHC058) |
**License caveats.** ALE-Bench is CC BY-ND 4.0 (no derivatives): its statements are reproduced verbatim and its tasks carry `license_restricted`; check that your use is compatible before redistributing modified versions. FrontierShift states no license (its repository is not public); those tasks carry `license_unknown`. AtCoder problem statements (ALE-Bench, EdgeBench) remain © AtCoder.
**`best_known` provenance.** Values are the published records where available (cited in `tests/instance.json` → `best_known_source`, hidden from the agent). For contest instances and several FrontierCS/ALE problems no per-instance record is published, so `best_known` is our own best solution (tag `best_known_uncertain`); agents can beat it and the reward clips at 1.
**Excluded in v2.** Anything overlapping the problem families of HorizonMath, HeuriGym or CO-Bench is left out at every size (e.g. Ramsey/Schur/van der Waerden colourings, kissing numbers, Tammes, spherical designs, difference bases, merit factor, codes and covering designs, Hadamard matrices, sphere packing, TSP/routing, scheduling, bin/rectangle/circle-unequal packing, facility location, set cover, graph colouring, MIS). Also skipped: constants whose certificate is a proof rather than an object, interactive or program-output problems, problems needing a GPU/network/hardware, and problems whose verifier could not be made sound and fast.
**Upstream verifier bugs found in v2 sources** (all fixed in our checkers):
- AlphaEvolve p6 scores a different functional than stated; p13 never checks f̂ ≥ 0; p14 truncates the Fourier integral; p33 clamps coincident points to distance 1e-12; the hexagon-packing outer side is taken as input, not computed; p40 scores the longest valid prefix plus a bonus; p55's sample layout overlaps; p56 silently drops duplicate lines; p57 drops coefficients below 1e-8.
- EdgeBench AHC058: the eval script reads any `Score = …` line, so a submission can forge the score.
- FrontierCS 58/8 compare counts only modulo primes; 192/176 ignore trailing tokens; 227 has no range check; 111 and 27 accept empty answers; 193 is a re-encoding of 192.
- FrontierCO MDS accepts `3.0`/`True` as node ids.
- ALE-Bench tools: ahc014 turn count wrong, ahc004 panics on Unicode whitespace, ahc024/041 accept an empty output at turn 0.
## License
Each row carries the license of its source (`license` column): MIT (93 families), CC-BY-4.0 (68), Apache-2.0 (32), CC-BY-ND-4.0 (18, ALE-Bench), unknown (8, FrontierShift). Attribution belongs to the original authors of each source listed above. Our packaging, checkers and generators are released under the same terms as the corresponding source.